Sunday, February 6, 2011

3D TV Review Shootout 2010 Samsung vs. Panasonic

Samsung PN50C8000 3D plasma vs. Panasonic TC-P50VT25 3D Plasma


Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Samsung PN50C8000 and Panasonic TC-P50VT25.
Picture Quality
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs on the Panasonic TC-P50VT25.

3D TV Viewing:

Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Same movie on the Samsung PN50C8000. Keep in mind that we are having to take the picture through one lense of the glasses. These picture do not accurately reflect the quality of the viewing image.

Advantage: Samsung PN50C8000
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
A shot from the Blu Ray version of Alexander shows vivid accurate colors on the Samsung PN50C8000
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
The same shot on the Panasonic TC-P50VT25 shows over saturation of color information

Advantage: Samsung PN50C8000
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Panasonic TC-P50VT25: This dark scene shot from the Blu Ray of Wyatt Earp reveals oversaturated blue tones in the Panasonic. Notice also the black bars top and bottom of the picture. The bars should be saturated black as they are on the Samsung below.
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
The same scene on the Samsung PN5C8000.

Contrast Ratio Measurement: The Panasonic TC-P50VT25 measured 2239:1 post calibration contrast ratio when the panel light was on high. The Samsung plasma registered 1716:1.

Advantage: Panasonic TC-P50VT25

Advantage: Even
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Samsung 3D Glasses (Left) Panasonic 3D Glasses (Right)
The VT25 comes with one pair of 3D glasses included while the C8000 does not. Both sets of glasses worked well and will fit over normal glasses (though maybe unconfortably).
Advantage: Samsung PN50C8000
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Pansonic VT25 (Left) - Samsung C8000 (Right)
Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
Pansonic VT25 (Left) - Samsung C8000 (Right)

Remote Control and Menu Functionality: The Samsung was again the clear winner with a superior menu system with more options, and a far nicer remote control

Samsung vs Panasonic 3DTV Shootout
The Samsung PN50C8000 Remote control is super while the Panasonic remote feels cheap)

Vizio XVT472SV vs. Sony KDL-46EX700 Review LED HDTV Costco Shootout

Models: Vizio XVT472SV vs. Sony KDL-46EX700
Description: 46" and 47" LED LCD TV
Resolution: 1920 X 1080
Power Consumption: 130W

We decided to do a side by side comparison review of these two intruiging offerings which can both be found for sale currently at Costco Wholesale Club. We reviewed the LED TVs with the same signal sources through the same inputs both post calibration. Our findings are mostly just fact but we've added some of our own thoughts and impressions as well. Both TVs are Spring 2010 models arriving now with similar feature sets including Hz rate upgrade to 120Hz or 240Hz, LED back lighting, and various other similarities. We highlight where the features and quality vary. Keep in mind what features are most important to you in using this guide to help you choose a TV manufacturer winner.

Sony vs. Vizio Shootout
This brightly lit computer generated image from the Blu Ray version of The Fifth Element displays in rich detail on both TVs.

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 11 feet

Calibration: Both TVs calibrated relatively easy to D6500K. Turning the brightness or contrast up on the Vizio XVT will cause color shift. Gamma was nearly perfect right out of the box on the Sony EX.
Advantage: Sony 46EX700

Sony vs. Vizio Shootout

Sony vs. Vizio Shootout
Another scene from The Fifth Element the Vizio XVT472SV struggles to maintain post calibration brightness compared to the Sony.

Black Level/Contrast Ratio: Black levels both tested better in our contrast ratio testing and looked better with content on the Sony 46EX600. The Vizio's black levels were decent but can look a bit washed out with certain content.
Advantage Sony 46EX700


Sony vs. Vizio Shootout
Note the dark shadow detail in Mark Walberg's shirt from both TVs in this scene from the Blu Ray version of The Departed. Shadow detail was a particular strength of the Sony and weakness of the Vizio.
Sony vs. Vizio Shootout
Color rendition was close on both TVs. Here colors displayed a little more vibrant and with better contrast on the Sony 46EX700.


120Hz/240/480Hz Rate Feature Evaluation: Vizio calls their back light manipulated 240Hz rate feature Smooth Motion and claims that the manipulation creates the effect of 480Hz.. Sony calls their 120Hz rate feature MotionFlow and makes no such claims about the backlighting. Vizio's SmoothMotion works better when panning side to side (it is indeed smooth) and we must derive with fast motion as well. The problem is that with most content the feature eliminates natural intended background blur thus making it undesirable for most programming. Without the feature of course there is visible judder and jerky effect when panning side to side.

In the Sony 46EX700 the opposite holds true. MotionFlow feature does not introduce unwelcome effects and may be used with all programming, but it does not work as effectively at eliminating jerky effects with side to side panning and other annoyances.
Even

Inputs: The Sony 46EX700 has all inputs you would presently need or want. The Vizio XVT472SV lacks an Ethernet port for Internet.
Advantage Sony 46EX700

Aesthetic Considerations: Though the XVT472SV has a thinner bezel framing of just an inch which we like but is a hefty 4.5" deep. The table top stand does not swivel. The Sony 46EX700 is just over 2" in depth and comes with a swivel table top stand. The only drawback being a slightly wider bezel.
Advantage Sony 46EX700 (just barely)

Sony vs. Vizio Shootout

Remote Control/Menu Funtionality: Neither remote control is backlit. The Vizio remote's top control buttons are too small, the Sony's very large but the remote is plain basic looking.
Even

Sony vs. Vizio Shootout

Audio Output: Sound volume output from Vizio XVT's 15W X 15W speakers was impressive as was the virtual surround effects and definition. The Sony's 10W X 10W inbuilt speakers were weak in volume and surround sound quality with a hollow sound.'
Advantage Vizio XVT472SV

Internet Options: The XVT472SV does not contain Internet options. Sony wins this contest with a fight.
Advantage Sony 46EX700

Price: At $1299 for the Vizio XVT472SV and $1549 for the Sony 46EX700 we'll give this one to Vizio.
Advantage Vizio XVT472SV

Sony 46EX700: Winner of 8 Categories

Vizio XVT472SV: Winner of 5 Categories

Even in 4 Categories

Rating scale from 70 (denoting poorest quality) to 100 (signifying the very best quality). A rating in the 60s for any particular category of a product review indicates a serious defect which causes the product not to operate properly. Picture quality is double-weighted in the Overall Rating Score calculation.

Samsung LN46C750 Review 46" LCD TV

Model: Samsung LN46C750 LCD TV
Description: 1920 X 1080 46" LCD 3D Compatible Television

Samsung LN46C750 Review
This is not HD. It's a beautifully unconverted shot from the a 480i DVD of Jaws.

The C750 series packs a strong punch with the new 3D TV compatibility feature combined with some of Samsung's best features from the past. Samsung isn't only producing LED backlit LCDs for 2010, the C750 line of CFL backlit LCDs contains many of the features of the more expensive LED TVs at a more affordable price. The C750 uses Samsung's 1080p, 240Hz "Ultra Clear" panel. While we found the motion blur reduction of the AutoMotion Plus 240Hz and 120Hz impressive during sports programming we didn't like the effect it had on picture depth in film programming. Other high hertz rate TVs didn't showcase this issue so we are hopeful that this has been remedied for 2010.

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 12


Picture Settings
Picture Mode: Movie
Color Temp: Warm 2
Brightness: 47
Contrast: 95
Color: 49
Tint: G49/R51
Sharpness: 0
Backlight: 7
Gamma: -1
Flesh Tone: 0
Digital NR: Auto
HDMI Black Level: Low
Auto Motion: Standard
For complete picture settings, see the LN46C750 Calibration Page

The CFL backlight on this TV is very strong and provides plenty of brightness. It's relatively easy to adjust the backlight for varying room conditions. By using the Movie setting, you are essentially deactivating the inbuilt new Eco Sensor feature. So we feel it's better to adjust the backlight on your own via the 20 point scale. This LCD TV has a tremendous CFL backlight. We needed only set the backlight at 7 from the 1 – 20 scale to achieve a desirable picture in a darkly lit room.

Processor Testing: The internal processing chip sets for the C750 series LCDs are very good. One of the first things we noticed during testing was hose crisp and clean edges were without adding unwanted edge enhancement artifacts. The Sharpness control should be kept low between 10 and 20. Using it at a higher level with produce nasty edge glow artifacts.

3D TV Viewing: We were able to view this TV with DirecTV 3D content at CES 2010 in a special viewing area using the provided 3D glasses. We noticed a strong eye strain when the scenes changed from frame to frame. The DirecTV content was not smooth or enjoyable to watch. As we have pointed out in many articles, the viewer will not see 1080p HD through both eyes in LCD TVs due to limitations in Hz the rate. I do not think this had anything to do with the eye strain we encountered. We believe that resulted from the rough up programming shown in a hurry at CES.

Samsung LN46C750 Review
This shot from Jaws shows just how good the TVs upconversion from 480i DVD is. Notice the crisp details in the jacket (anchors).

Up conversion from 480i and 480p: In the past we have harped on the importance of the AutoMotion Plus 240Hz or 120Hz technology contained in this and most all of Samsung's LCD and LED TV offerings. The importance of the performance of this feature past and present cannot be overstated. In the 2009 series B750 series we recommended turning off the 240Hz feature for all but sports programming due to the unpleasant side effects produced when the feature eliminates the natural background blur of the picture. We believe the feature is much better this year albeit still intrusive for some viewing. Our recommendation is to follow a Custom setting for this feature of Motion Blur 10 and Judder Reduction 2 when viewing 480i DVD and normal non-HD broadcast content. This will eliminate a lot of motion blur while not introducing an artificial looking picture which reminds you of a soap opera. See our instruction below under the Features section about how to get to this feature setting.

Samsung LN46C750 Review
Another good detail shot from Jaws.

With this modification, I enjoyed the picture presentation on the C750 very much even with 480i or broadcast content. The Ultra Clear screen panel produces a magnifying effect brings scenes to life. Images are crisp, black levels remain very rich, and color is impressive. There is very good light flow through the picture which allows for lots of detail even in dark scenes. Surprisingly, side viewing are solid even with 480i content without degradation of blacks and contrast.

720p/1080i/1080p Picture Quality: Black levels and contrast are very pronounced on this TV. Images are crisp and the detail is amazing with HD sources. The big decision is whether or not to engage the 240Hz Automotion feature or leave it off. It does introduce some unrealistic effects. My recommendation is to either leave it off entirely (except for sports programming) and get used to some judder and motion blur, or use the custom setting mentioned above.

Samsung LN46C750 Review
Contrast, color, and dark shadow detail; this shot from the HD Blu Ray version of Master and Commander.

After tuning the 240Hz feature, high definition content appears vibrant, realistic and extremely crisp. Blacks are rich for an LCD and contrast is a strength. One of the strength features of the LN46C750 is the unusual amount of displayed depth for an LCD TV. The aforementioned Ultra Clear panel has most to do with this. Colors are very rich but not oversaturated.

Black Level/Contrast/Contrast Ratio: Black Levels on the C750 series LCD 3D TV is super saturated, as black as the glossy black bezel surrounding the screen. We believe contrast is also enhanced by the Ultra Clear Panel that Samsung uses for this LCD TV. Contrast is very impressive on this TV even compared to plasma TVs.

Dark Shadow Detail: Though black levels are excellent we thought shadow detail was still good with most material due to the TVs very bright backlight capability.

Samsung LN46C750 Review
Roy's House in 480i DVD of Jaws. Great color and contrast.

Color Rendition/Color Accuracy: Colors are bright, rich and vibrant but not oversaturated. The color rendition of this TV is exceptional.

Viewing Angle/Off Axis Viewing: There is negligible to no degradation of contrast and black levels at angles even 35 degrees off center. An exceptional result for an LCD TV with a CFL backlight. Samsung has the only CFL backlit TVs in the market with this quality.

Picture Glare: The more anti glare technology a TV contains, the less depth appearance with the picture images (and also hazy blacks and poor side angle contrast). Though the C650 does contain some effective anti glare technology, it does not interfere with the depth and beauty of the images. There is some glare though, so be prepared for that. To us the best scenario is a little anti glare technology and lots of picture depth and rich blacks. The C650 does just that.

Motion Lag: There is much less motion blur and judder effect with the C650 than with past models. With 480i content it is still prominently there with the 120Hz feature turned off, but with the HD content it's negligible even with the feature off.

False Contouring/ Mapping: We noted slight mapping effects in some dark content, but it was not a significant down point.

Samsung LN32C450 Review

Model: Samsung LN32450
Description: 32" LCD TV
Resolution: 1366 X 768 (720p)
Power Consumption: Not listed
Samsung LN32C450 Review


Samsung's 2010 4 Series LCDs are a step up from the 3 series. Available in the same sizes they still feature a 60Hz, 720p, CFL backlit panel, with SRS TruSurround HD. They add a third HDMI input, the ability to watch video off a USB thumb drive and Samsung's AnyNet+ which allows communication between similarly equipped Samsung home theater equipment. The 4 Series LCD make for an excellent TV for the bedroom, a child's room or other rooms where you need a smaller, less expensive HDTV.

Test and Optimum Viewing Distance: 8 feet

Calibrating to near D65 was fairly easy. With smaller TVs we are not quite as concerned with pinpoint accuracy to D65. However, the below picture settings will get you close. There are more white balance controls and advanced settings than I anticipated based on size and price, such as Black Tone, Dynamic Contrast, a Gamma setting, and a nifty Flesh Tone setting that will take the onscreen flesh tones from a yellowish to a pinkish appearance at your whim without changing the overall color appearance of the picture much.

Follow these picture settings for the LN32C450 LCD.

Backlight: 8 Black Tone: Dark
Contrast: 91 Dynamic Contrast: Low
Brightness: 47 Gamma: +1
Sharpness: 13 Color Space: Native
Color: 52 White Balance: Rgain: 27, Roffset 24
Tint: Unchanged Flesh Tone: +1
Edge Enhancement: Off

Testing for Motion Artifacts: Samsung did not cut corners on the processing video boards contained in the LN32C450. We were fairly impressed with testing results.

Samsung LN32C450 Review
The LN32C450 did a good job with various processor tests results. There was little motion artifacts during the Video Resolution Loss Test.

Picture Quality Performance: With 480i images we noted some jerky motion artifacts in the background of some scenes. However, I did not see much offensive negatives in the foreground and was very pleased with the detail offered in 480i. The processors did a very nice job. Color rendition was not oversaturated, if not sometimes a little muted.

Samsung LN32C450 Review
This scene from the Blu Ray HD version of S.W.A.T. Shows a bright background and good contrast in the foreground without losing detail.

With our Blu Ray set to 720p resolution to match the TVs resolution we were very impressed at the bright sharp images and intense color offered. The TV really has a lot of pop with HD material. We also did not note the negative background judder with HD material and this proved out with our HD HQV processor testing as well. Black levels were deep and occasionally oversaturated but not often enough to really be a strike against. Dark shadow detail was totally acceptable for a TV of this size and price range.

Samsung LN32C450 Review
This scene from HD scene from S.W.A.T shows no dithering artifacts in the background blinds and good shadow effects.

Off center viewing was average on this LCD TV with the contrast and black levels fading at around 35 degrees off angle – again not bad for this price range.

On a negative note, there was notable loss of contrast and black levels at a 35 degree angle. This is not uncommon for LCD TVs. It's a problem that LCD TV manufacturers have attempted to somewhat alleviate with the introduction of LED backlighting. The idea has been marginally successful.

LG 55LE5500 Review - 55" LCD LED TV

Model: LG 55LE5500
Description: 55" LCD TV with 240Hz Processing
Resolution: 1980 X 1080
Includes: Swivel table top stand

LG 55LE5500 Review
This shot from the standard definition DVD of Braveheart shows the LE5500's back light and contrast capabilities

The LE5500 has LG's new LED backlight with local dimming option. There is a control to enable on/off functionality of this option. The unit has the Clear Voice II feature for voice/dialog enhancement and LG's full Internet options. While we were not a fan of the TruMotion 240Hz feature in most circumstances, it will certainly standout for sports programming. The LE5500 does not have the thick single sheet of glass overlay extending from edge to edge that the higher end LED offerings have.

Samsung UN46C9000 Review LED HDTV, 3D Ready

Description: Samsung UN46C9000 46” LCD TV with LED backlighting, 240Hz, 3D Compatible


Samsung UN46C9000 Review
A vibrant shot from The Fifth Element shows off hot colors from the UN46C9000

Strengths

  • 3D Compatible
  • Appearance/Aesthetics brushed Titanium
  • Bright, strong colors excellent picture
  • Deep black levels
  • Internet Apps with optional wifi
  • 240Hz for Sports programming
  • Picture upgrading Standard Definition Programs
  • Super Cool Touch Screen Remote Control has on screen content viewing option
Samsung UN55C9000 Review
Calibrating Brightness